Post-Cinema
By
Joel Blackledge
Published on/by
Accompanying text
This video explores Francesco Casetti’s (2015) concept of ‘recognition’ in post-cinema as it applies to scholarship in that field. Casetti defines the cinematic as an experience—a way of sensing—which can be relocated to different screens, practices, and contexts. Beyond how an image looks, cinema is recognised as such according to the idea of cinema that audiences perform in rituals of spectatorship, memories, imagination, and other contextual factors around the image itself. The changing shape of cinema is then a matter of which of its aspects are ‘recognised’ and which are ignored. Post-cinema is therefore both the persistence and transformation of this idea of cinema amidst technological and cultural changes, and to study it is to pay attention to the tensions generated by these two processes. “Post-Cinema: The Hall of Mirrors” is an explication of this concept and the first of a series of video essays produced for my doctoral research on internet memes. While it stands alone, the video is also an attempt to configure a kind of videographic practice that will allow me to analyse internet memes as post-cinematic media.
For this video, I translate Casetti’s act of recognition into a visual metaphor and use the videographic genre of the supercut to draw out the implications of Casetti’s argument for post-cinema scholarship. The metaphor I use is the ‘mirror routine’, a type of performance (far pre-dating cinema) in which one performer mimics another. Perhaps the most famous example comes from Duck Soup (dir. Leo McCarey, 1933), where Harpo Marx mimics Groucho Marx in place of a destroyed mirror. I begin with this image and follow a supercut trail through other variations on the scenario of a character looking in a mirror and seeing something that is almost—but not quite—their own reflection. As each image contains an imperfect reflection, it also imperfectly reflects the images either side of it. Typical mirror routines become distorted reflections, interfaces with the mirror itself, and mimicry without a mirror at all. The result is both a procession of sameness and an accumulation of difference. This is also the reason for the use of Maurice Ravel’s Boléro (1928), a piece of music that generates tension between melodic repetition and dynamic transformation. The mirror routine therefore stands in for post-cinematic recognition: facing something that is understood to be a mirror (no matter the material differences) and seeing a reflection that contains differences but is nonetheless recognisable. As Casetti notes, ‘“almost” can mean “not at all,” but it can also mean “nearly completely”’ (2015: 31). Cinema is recognisable not only despite the differences but because of them: cinema is a thing that shapeshifts.
The metaphor takes on a secondary level in the logic of the supercut genre itself, a cinephilic video form that indicates a fannish, completionist, and even obsessive attention paid to film texts (de Fren 2020). This kind of spectatorship typically runs contrary to the ephemeral internet meme, yet with its database logic and remix ethos the supercut is also a quintessentially online form. In a nod to post-cinematic breakdown of medium specificity, the steady pace of the images suggests a rolling film strip, a walk through a gallery, and the digital scroll of a website or app. For Ian Garwood (2020), the critical capacities of the supercut are best understood when it is framed as a kind of distant reading as practiced in the digital humanities. Creatively recontextualising images in volume can ‘activate thinking in the viewer about the knowledge effects these audiovisual combinations can yield’ (14). In this case, it prompts the viewer to reflect on how the scrolling images are the same as each other, and how they are different. With no original explanatory text but select quotes from Casetti, the audience are further encouraged to apply these questions to cinema itself. This is an intentional use of what Garwood calls the video essay’s ‘excess of meaning’ (25): the images speak for themselves, both to the audience and to each other.
If the mirror routine is a metaphor for the process of recognition in cinema, then the hall of mirrors—the visual theme of the final part of the video—is a methodological mission statement for post-cinema scholarship. It signifies the deliberate march into disorientation and uncertainty, enacting recognition in multiple directions at once—including beyond the bounds of what would previously have been recognised as cinema. The video climaxes with clips sourced from TikTok, each an instance of a meme format whereby the performer lip-syncs multiple song parts in a three-panelled mirror. In the one remaining cinematic image, Bruce Lee’s careful steeliness is repurposed as he is surrounded by these new-yet-familiar images, connoting both a scepticism and resolve required to navigate the post-cinematic hall of mirrors.
One of the foundational values for post-cinema is that cinema—as an idea, institution, or set of practices—is plural. Yet despite all connections, memes belong to distinct social and technological histories different than cinema’s (something indicated by the switch to a vertical scroll). I aim, in my research practice, to creatively perform my own processes of post-cinematic recognition upon them. In other words, I make sense of them both as and with cinema. In doing so, I want to demonstrate not only the persistence of a topos (used here as a metaphor), but also that cinematic and memetic processes of sense-making are similar: an ongoing and unresolved flux of imitation, reflection, and imperfect recognition. Videographic practices like this can usefully explore those processes and clear methodological ground for the post-cinematic analysis of internet memes.
Works Cited
Casetti, F. (2015) The Lumière Galaxy: Seven Key Words for the Cinema to Come. Columbia University Press.
de Fren, A. (2020) “The Critical Supercut: A Scholarly Approach to a Fannish Practice.” The Cine-Files, 15.
Garwood, I. (2020) “From ‘Video Essay’ to ‘Video Monograph’?: Indy Vinyl as Academic Book. NECSUS: European Journal of Media Studies, 9(1), pp. 5–29.
Biography
Joel Blackledge is a writer, filmmaker, and doctoral researcher at Birmingham City University. His research looks at the ways in which internet memes, as post-cinematic media, evidence both the persistence and transformation of cinematic aesthetics, practices, and ideas.

